The Boxing Rabbi Takes a Punch


It may dismay readers of this blog to know that the Boxing Rabbi occasionally gets hit, and hard.  There is an adage in boxing that “the punch that puts you down is the one you don’t see” and I have found that to be true.  The few times that I have been hurt while sparring it was from a punch that I never saw coming.

I was one of the few who publicly said that I considered Mr Netanyahu’s effort to undermine Mr Obama’s foreign policy by speaking to Congress bad form, not done, “past nisht” as they say in Yiddish, even maybe harmful to the American-Israel partnership.    I said this even though in many ways I consider Israel to be my true “home”, and the defense of Israel the most important community project of the Jewish people in our time.    I say this even though my wife comes from a prominent Zionist family, founders of the State.  What I never saw coming was the advance reframing of the speech by Mr Netanyahu’s people, working alongside American counterparts.  In this reframing, it is 1938, Obama is Neville Chamberlain, and Netanyahu is Churchill.   Everywhere I went yesterday, and in almost every essay I read, people spoke of Mr Netanyahu as Churchill reborn, and expressed deep admiration for his courage and plain spoken willingness to defend the Jewish people from all harm.  From that perspective, Mr Netanyahu’s speech was a stunning success.  Those Jews who opposed the speech, were at best naive and foolish, at worst; well, one of my friends who opposed the speech was labeled a member of the “Judenrat”-Jews who collaborated with Nazis.

So be it.  I’ve taken worse punches, and always managed to get up again, sometimes with a really bad headache.   But before the American political class seeks to turn Congress into the Knesset, remember that the Knesset is a messy place, often filled with shouting, name-calling, and  occasional fisticuffs.  Just the other day an Arab member of the Knesset, a woman, was assaulted by a supporter of a right wing political party, just for showing up to a panel discussion.  Israeli politics is even more complicated than American politics, and that is saying a lot.   In lionizing Mr Netanyahu and in embracing his view as the true path we are taking an enormous chance-choosing, as it were, to follow the lead of an Israeli political party leader facing a close re-election at home.  I pray, I truly and sincerely pray, for the sake of Israel and for the sake of the Jewish people, that it is the right choice.


2 thoughts on “The Boxing Rabbi Takes a Punch

  1. As the old adage says…2 Jews, 3 opinions.
    I have to believe that in some way Netanyahu (henceforth Bibi) whether covertly or overtly knows what is being negotiated with Iran. What he has expressed is a more credible agreement or else the alternative which is “no deal is better than a bad deal”. Bibi uses the example of a “Persian Marketplace”, where if you walk away you will be called back with a better offer. Every one of the nuclear nations (Israel included) has a clandestine nuclear program. Why would Iran’s program be any different. What would be the penalties if Iran does not comply with the agreement? What happens after 10 years when the “deal” expires. The United States is only 231 years old. What is 10 years in the life of a nation, in this case Israel. Finally, can you negotiate with Iran, a nation that has vowed to obliterate Israel, to make a deal that would have such a profound effect on the very future of the JEWISH STATE.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s